The Disentangler "Don't be entangled..." Galatians 5:1
May 2006

Greetings!

Welcome to the first issue of The Disentangler, Ill-Legalism.com's regular newsletter. Our goal is to help "recovering legalists" find a way to enjoy the liberty of living in the Grace of Jesus without drowning themselves in the deep end of anarchy. We are not here to discuss everything that is wrong with "the church" or to rail against those who do things differently from us. Instead we are dedicated to finding positive, constructive ways to engage the culture - Christian and secular - with the good news of God's grace. Explore this issue and let us know what you think.

In this issue
  • What is Legalism?
  • First Person: Imperfection and Ill-Legalism
  • Featured Book Review - Telling Secrets
  • Gamaliel's Desk - Recent Posts
  • From Bad News Religion:
  • Our Ad-Mission

  •  
    First Person: Imperfection and Ill-Legalism

    Rose Marie Smith from the Ill-legalism Story group shares this:
    I don’t think I have been bitter...just disheartened by the callousness that I felt from people that I thought would be sensitive and understanding when my life was at a very difficult stage. Sadly, I believe now that my experiences aren’t that unique.


     
    Featured Book Review - Telling Secrets

    Fans of Brian McLaren will find a lot to love about his latest book, The Secret Message of Jesus.

    Critics of Brian McLaren will find a lot to condemn about his latest book, The Secret Message of Jesus.

    McLaren seems to elicit such polarized response whenever he puts pen to paper and his latest offering is no exception. Polemicists on either side of the divide between Evangelicals and Emergents have plenty of ammunition now that McLaren has clarified much of the doctrinal ambiguity in his previous books. To the satisfaction of some and chagrin of others, he has finally taken a firm position on a number of issues that were previously open to discussion...


     
    Gamaliel's Desk - Recent Posts

    Who is Gamaliel?

    Pastor Gamaliel, the spiritual leader of the First Pharisee Church, is widely respected in the Pharisee denomination for his outspoken, hard-hitting commentaries on what is wrong with society at large and Christianity in particular. A graduate of Grace Pharisee Bible College, pastor Gamaliel has been involved in pursuing spiritual excellence his entire ministerial career. While his congregation, and indeed his denomination, is small, thanks to the power of the Internet, Gamaliel’s discourses, diatribes and disputes can be read by all those in need of spiritual direction. Eschewing political correctness and promoting candor and confrontation, Gamaliel dispenses sage wisdom for anyone who wants to know exactly what it takes to be a spiritual Christian. For all others too weak or carnal to pursue the disciplined life of a dedicated disciple of legalistic (see Legalism) conformity to external standards of conduct, Gamaliel serves as a warning.

    "Even though I was raised in a Pharisee church by Pharisee parents, graduated from a Pharisee Christian school, went to a Pharisee Bible College and have only attended Pharisee churches all my life, my beliefs are not influenced one bit by my upbringing or culture. They are strictly a product of sound Biblical exegesis and applied study. This is because "no prophecy of the scripture is of any private interpretation" and Pharisee churches take a high view of the Bible. While our beliefs may be unique to the Pharisee church, it is because we are the only ones who rightly divide the Word of Truth. How do I know this to be true? It is because I only study Pharisee theologians and read Pharisee commentators."


    Following are some recent selections from his blog. To read them in their entirity, visit Gamaliel's Desk.

    Clothesline Conformity
    In all of the preachers conferences I have attended, I find the same burning questions. "What are we doing wrong? Why do so many of our preachers and pastors look, act and talk like the world? How can it be that preachers, who are supposed to be set apart for God and sheltered from worldly influence are indistinguishable in language, appearance and conduct from the world?"

    At every single conference, I saw preachers – yes, preachers! – dressing just like the world. It was abominable. Why, this group of preachers was indistinguishable from any group of businessmen, politicians or lawyers. Every last one of them was dressed in a suit and looked fit to join the ranks of greedy robber barons, crooked politicians or lying lawyers. We could have droped the whole lot of them down in a joint session of congress or a meeting of the Trial Lawyers Association and we couldn't tell who was a man of God and who was a worldling, based solely on appearance.

    Legalistic Hypocrites and Hypocritical Legalists
    I don't know how many times I have been called a legalist simply because I believe in setting standards of decency and decorum for church attendees and workers. I am fed up with these slanderous and hypocritical accusations. Let me state for the record that I do not have a problem with legalism because I am not a legalist. And people who accuse me of such are hypocrites because they want to apply their standard of legalism to my expression of the Christian faith. What they really object to is how I tell them they are wrong for holding to the error of their ways, but they have no objection to telling me that I am wrong. If this is not the height of hypocrisy, I don't know what is. Truth be told, I never make personal, slanderous accusations about them. I only point out the Truth of God's Word, while they levy ad hominem attacks against me of a very personal nature even to the point of questioning my very salvation. Of course, most of my critics are unsaved to begin with, but if they were, I would never question their personal relationship to God as they do mine...

    Autobiographical Moral Norms
    People ask me why I am so hard on rock music and why I make such a big deal about the dangers of contemporary Christian music. Let me share my testimony and you will see why. During my 20's God saved me by his marvelous grace out of the rock & roll culture. I was as addicted to the music as I was addicted to the drugs, the sex, the lifestyle and the wantonness. The life that I lived then was a life of profligacy, debauchery and shame and I thank God that he had saved me out of it...

     


     
    From Bad News Religion:

    By Greg Albrecht

    "Legalism often adorns itself in a Christian uniform, and as a part of this disguise it talks the talk, paying lip service to God's grace." (41)

    "Preaching and teaching that judges Christians solely upon external actions almost inevitably leads to manipulation for the purpose of creating guilt and shame." (43)

    "Because of the lies of legalism many of its followers never realize that religious externalism is an illusion, a spiritual mirage, the religious equivalent of the Emperor's new clothes." (54)


     
    What is Legalism?
    When we talk about legalism, we often find ourselves in discussion about what the term actually means. The most common definition I've found for legalism is, "Anyone who is stricter than I am." This definition may apply in some circumstances but it is decidedly unhelpful when talking about legalism in general.
    Pastor Drew Walther of Johnstown Independent Baptist Church (OH) recently shed some light on Colossians 2:8, "Beware lest any man spoil you though philosophy and vain deceit, after the tradition of men, after the rudiments of the world, and not after Christ." He summarized the topic with these points:
    • Legalism is something that we think other people suffer from, but we don't have the problem ourselves - when in fact we often do...
    • Legalism compares ourselves to others...

    Find out more....

    Quick Links...

    Ill-Legalism Home

    Ill-Legalism Book Reviews

    Ill-Legalism Discussion Group

    More About Us

    Gamaliel's Desk



     
    Join our mailing list!